It has kept well a couple of weeks and may last even longer but has always been eaten! If I put the pizza in for a couple more minutes, I risk burning the crust and top of the pizza, and the middle always seems to still be doughy. Every time I bake my papa Murphy's stuffed pizza, the middle layer of dough is always undercooked. 4) Then put your pizza on your baking stone and finish baking per the directions that came with the pizza. For 2 burner grills, use both burners and heat to 375°–400°F. When you are ready to eat the pizza, bake it in the oven. Now Papa Murphy’s is featuring a brand new item on the menu, it’s called Fresh Pan Pizza and it’s available in medium, large and family size. Cook 12-18 minutes (32-40 minutes for stuffed) rotating a quarter turn halfway through cooking. You can view the entire Pan Pizza Menu Here. This step is important! Whether you freeze a whole or portion of an unbaked pizza, I wrap it tight in plastic wrap and then in heavy foil. Remove pizza from plastic and leave pizza on paper tray. Once cheese is melted and crust is golden brown on bottom, remove and let cool 5 minutes before slicing. For grills with 3 or more burners, heat to 425°–450°F, and light outer burners only. Plate setter legs down with pizza stone directly on it cook pizza still in paper tray and have never burned one yet. Papa Murphy's offers take-and-bake pizzas made with fresh ingredients. Best way to bake Papa Murphy's stuffed pizzas? Best For: Heating Single Slices Total Time Required: 5-7 Minutes Overall Rating: A. I never thought to reheat pizza in my skillet before writing this article. Preheating 30 min is critical as is a clean firebox (as usual). The pan pizza is a thicker crust with a light layer of buttery oil to give you a crispy yet soft crust. Like the microwave method, this one requires virtually zero prep time. Ensure the pizza lays flat in the freezer and does not bend or move the toppings out of place. It takes maybe 20 minutes cook time at 425F, but check on it at 10min and rotate pizza 180dg. 2) Start baking your Papa Murphy's Pizza on the original try for 10 minutes. 3) Pull your Papa Murphy's Pizza out and remove it from the original tray with a good-sized pizza peel. It doesn’t get easier or taste any better! Yes you can, we have done so many times. Preheat grill. Turns out, reheating your pizza in a skillet is actually the best way to reheat pizza for single slices. If you order a pizza and cannot bake it that day, freeze it.